#43AMERICANS

Forty-three cases. The process was the punishment.

Twenty-seven of the people below have a clemency petition pending with the Office of the Pardon Attorney. Two have already been pardoned. Nine have nothing to file, because there is no conviction left to forgive — they were acquitted, their charges were dismissed, or an appeals court threw the verdict out. One was never charged with anything.

Being cleared did not make any of them whole. Lucky Ott was acquitted before the jury finished deliberating, in a state he had never set foot in. He had already spent everything he owned defending himself. Nobody gives that back. Dr. Raj Bothra was denied bail nine times and held three and a half years before a jury cleared him. Mark Sorensen served all forty-two months, and then the Seventh Circuit ruled there had never been enough evidence to convict him.

That is what these forty-three cases have in common. Not a verdict — the government won some and lost others. What they share is the cost of being put through it. Where a claim is contested here, it is written as a claim. Nothing asks you to take anyone's word for it.

In federal custody now 12

Twelve are in a cell today. Every one of them has a clemency petition pending.

Reporting to custody 3

Three have surrender dates on the calendar. Nothing about their cases changes on those days except where they sleep.

Still before a court 3

Not convicted, or convicted and awaiting a second look.

Out, still carrying it 10

A federal case does not end at the prison gate. It follows a licence, a mortgage, a job application.

Cleared, and never made whole 11

Acquitted, dismissed, reversed or pardoned. There is nothing left for most of them to petition for. They are here because the years, the legal bills and the reputations are not returned when a case ends.

Mike McMahon, a retired NYPD sergeant who was at the towers on 11 September, received a full pardon in November 2025, and the Second Circuit vacated his conviction the following year. He is the reason to keep filing. He is also thirty-one years of service, a pre-dawn raid on his family home, and years of his life that the pardon did not return to him. Relief arrives. It arrives late, it arrives to the well-represented first, and it does not undo what the process already cost.